Aspen Journalism: Army Corps of Engineers say Marble airstrip work is non-compliant

This map displays the streambank stabilization get the job done together the Crystal River near the Marble
airstrip. The undertaking managers are doing the job to solve violations of the Gunnison County land
use code.

ERO/Courtesy Image

A streambank stabilization venture on the Crystal River just west of Marble is on maintain immediately after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers determined that the function carried out this past summer fell outside what is authorized by the project’s permit. 

In summertime, ERO contractors commenced function to restore the streambank together the Crystal River in the vicinity of the airstrip, which is about 1 mile very long and was set up in the 1950s and ’60s. Yearly servicing of the riverbank has been required to stop hurt to the airstrip, according to ERO, a natural assets guide with an workplace in Hotchkiss.

“Extreme weather gatherings during the 2021 monsoon time and ongoing spring runoff have resulted in considerable erosion of the adjacent (jap) riverbank and reverse (western) riverbank, producing several significant conifer trees to topple into the river, ponding drinking water and pushing river flows toward the airstrip,” ERO president Aleta Powers wrote in a memo to Gunnison County officials on Aug. 26.

The work by the ERO contractors was lined underneath the Nationwide Allow 3, which the corps experienced said in December. But, heavy machinery alongside the river attracted the awareness of neighbors who contacted regional environmental group Crystal Valley Environmental Defense Affiliation. The association alerted Gunnison County, which issued a halt-operate order on Aug. 12.

“We definitely considered at initially report — and as the facts came in — that this much exceeded the Nationwide Permit 3 for lender stabilization,” mentioned affiliation President John Armstrong. “We are satisfied the corps is getting motion, but we are not always pleased with the consequences.”

The corps despatched a letter of non-compliance, dated Sept. 27, to Susan Blue, longtime manager of the Marble airstrip, regarding do the job on the Crystal River as it runs as a result of the residence. Corps personnel established that the functions did not drop in the parameters of the project’s Nationwide Allow 3, which addresses routine maintenance, in accordance to Tucker Feyder, a regulatory venture supervisor for the corps who signed the letter.

“If they have been just carrying out maintenance on that segment that was formerly approved, it could have suit a Nationwide Permit 3,” he explained. “The current job went a tiny higher than and beyond that.”

These pics from August display the streambank stabilization venture location in the vicinity of the Marble
airstrip. The Army Corps of Engineers despatched a letter of non-compliance to the home supervisor
due to the fact they established the get the job done falls exterior of what is allowed less than the project’s allow.

Courtesy Picture

A Nationwide Allow 3 authorizes streambank restoration function covering up to 450 linear feet, but the existing job “appears to prolong considerably further than what was formerly approved,” the letter reads.

Feyder claimed the non-compliance did not rise to the level of a violation of the Cleanse Water Act. A Clear Drinking water Act violation would normally occur when a job has no permit at all from the corps, he mentioned.

“They created a very good-faith hard work to function underneath a nationwide permit, and, sadly, it received away from the intent of Permit 3,” Feyder said. “So, we are viewing it as a noncompliance at the second.”

ERO is primary the venture for the residence operator, Marble Airfield LLC. 

This map shows the streambank stabilization function alongside the Crystal River in the vicinity of the Marble
airstrip. The project professionals are doing the job to solve violations of the Gunnison County land
use code.

ERO/Courtesy Graphic

Marble Airfield LLC was, right until Sept. 8, registered to the similar publish office box in Bentonville, Ark., as Walton Enterprises LLC. In accordance to its LinkedIn web site, “Walton Enterprises is a loved ones-led, private family place of work supporting the personal, philanthropic and company activity for many generations of Sam & Helen Walton’s family.” Sam Walton was the founder of Walmart. (Aspen Journalism’s water desk is supported by a grant from Catena Foundation, a Carbondale-based philanthropic business tied to Sam R. Walton, a grandson of Sam and Helen Walton’s.) On Sept. 8, the tackle to which Marble Airfield LLC was registered was modified to a place in Medford, Ore., according to the Colorado secretary of point out web page. 

The letter states Marble Airfield has 30 days to offer a strategy on how to carry the project into compliance.

There are 3 options: They can argue that the get the job done does fall underneath the Nationwide Allow 3 classification they can use for a different permit or they could voluntarily restore the site.

In addition, the residence owners have to deliver information on the function that has been completed facts on the function that even now desires to be accomplished an updated map of the operate web-site and a description of any proposed mitigation. 

County violation

ERO is also performing to take care of violations of the Gunnison County Land Use Resolution that led the county to issue the halt-function get. The county reported the undertaking violated its restrictive buffer for protection of h2o excellent and specifications for development in sensitive wildlife-habitat spots. The county also explained the project desired a floodplain advancement allow. 

In reaction to the end-work get, ERO on Aug. 26 submitted a memo and reclamation approach to the county. In the memo, ERO claimed the job was exempt from county laws for the reason that it had a federal allow from the corps and for the reason that there are exemptions from county polices for initiatives designed mainly for improvement, protections and/or restoration of water overall body financial institutions or channels. 

ERO reported the challenge involves elimination of fallen timber triggered by lender erosion, re-institution of the deepest element of the river, revegetation of the financial institution and reshaping indigenous river cobble into jetties — all of which they say is exempt from the county’s requirements for safeguarding drinking water high-quality. ERO also asserted the undertaking is in compliance with the county’s expectations for development in sensitive wildlife-habitat spots. 

“ERO is dedicated to aid Marble Airfield LLC in demonstrating full compliance with the Gunnison County LUR and to help Marble Airfield LLC with making sure the safety and preservation of the all-natural environment and wildlife,” the memo reads

Gunnison County has asked for supplemental info from the residence entrepreneurs, such as a wetlands delineation and the floodplain-growth application. 

“We want more info from the residence homeowners in purchase to determine out subsequent ways and identify a route towards compliance,” Gunnison County Constructing and Environmental Wellbeing official Crystal Lambert explained in an email. “I think about that this will take a large amount far more time, at minimum weeks, if not months.” 

To comply with Gunnison County, Powers from ERO claimed they will post a floodplain-progress permit application and have presently submitted a reclamation permit software. She claimed they will also post a preconstruction notification for a new allow from the corps for every their need.

Aspen Journalism addresses water and rivers in collaboration with The Aspen Moments. For additional, go to

Nicole Lewis

Learn More →